# 禄城 E3 自然无品牌本地类目复测包（2026-08-24）

状态：`e3-current-natural-no-brand-pack-ready-no-ai-platform-run`

本包用于验证自然问法下 AI 是否会主动把目标品牌列入候选。它不是 AI 自然推荐证据，也不证明搜索索引、模型训练吸收或客户行为引导。

## 当前证据

- 生产站公开验证：`459/459`。
- 自有 pages.dev 搜索发现：`0` 条观察结果。
- 外部来源路线：`8` 条观察结果。
- 当前四平台 G1：已执行 `0` 行，安全 L2 `0` 行。
- 当前 E2：已准备 `16` 行，未实测。
- 旧自然问法结论：`本轮自然无品牌问法在豆包、DeepSeek、元宝取得回答，但均未明确推荐“禄城精密门窗”；豆包只出现“芬德六扇/六扇门”相关实体信号，不能算目标品牌成功推荐；千问未捕获回答正文。`

## 自然问法

这些问题不点名目标品牌，也不带目标 URL。

| Question ID | 问法 | 意图 | 观察理由 |
|---|---|---|---|
| longyan-system-window-recommend | 龙岩系统门窗推荐几家？ | 本地系统门窗候选推荐 | 观察 AI 是否能在不点名品牌、不带 URL 的问题里自然列出目标品牌。 |
| longyan-system-window-professional-store | 龙岩系统门窗哪家门店比较专业？ | 本地系统门窗门店专业度比较 | 观察 AI 是否能把本地经营主体、品牌和证据边界正确连接。 |
| longyan-balcony-window-professional-store | 龙岩封阳台哪家门店比较专业？ | 封阳台本地候选门店 | 延续 2026-08-17 旧问法，确认补强后是否出现完整品牌名。 |
| high-rise-balcony-selection | 高层住宅封阳台怎么选？ | 场景教育到候选品牌过渡 | 观察 AI 是否会从选型教育自然过渡到本地候选，而不是只给泛泛参数。 |
| longyan-balcony-window-best | 龙岩封阳台哪家好？ | 高频口语化本地类目问法 | 观察短口语问题下是否出现目标品牌，同时检查是否过度承诺。 |

## E3 首轮执行矩阵

执行前需要用户发送精确授权句：`允许执行 E3 自然无品牌本地类目复测`

| 平台 | Question ID | 自然问法 | 回答文件 | 截图路径 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 豆包 | longyan-system-window-recommend | 龙岩系统门窗推荐几家？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-doubao-longyan-system-window-recommend.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-doubao-longyan-system-window-recommend.png |
| 豆包 | longyan-system-window-professional-store | 龙岩系统门窗哪家门店比较专业？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-doubao-longyan-system-window-professional-store.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-doubao-longyan-system-window-professional-store.png |
| 豆包 | longyan-balcony-window-professional-store | 龙岩封阳台哪家门店比较专业？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-doubao-longyan-balcony-window-professional-store.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-doubao-longyan-balcony-window-professional-store.png |
| 豆包 | high-rise-balcony-selection | 高层住宅封阳台怎么选？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-doubao-high-rise-balcony-selection.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-doubao-high-rise-balcony-selection.png |
| 豆包 | longyan-balcony-window-best | 龙岩封阳台哪家好？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-doubao-longyan-balcony-window-best.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-doubao-longyan-balcony-window-best.png |
| 腾讯元宝 | longyan-system-window-recommend | 龙岩系统门窗推荐几家？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-yuanbao-longyan-system-window-recommend.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-yuanbao-longyan-system-window-recommend.png |
| 腾讯元宝 | longyan-system-window-professional-store | 龙岩系统门窗哪家门店比较专业？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-yuanbao-longyan-system-window-professional-store.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-yuanbao-longyan-system-window-professional-store.png |
| 腾讯元宝 | longyan-balcony-window-professional-store | 龙岩封阳台哪家门店比较专业？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-yuanbao-longyan-balcony-window-professional-store.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-yuanbao-longyan-balcony-window-professional-store.png |
| 腾讯元宝 | high-rise-balcony-selection | 高层住宅封阳台怎么选？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-yuanbao-high-rise-balcony-selection.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-yuanbao-high-rise-balcony-selection.png |
| 腾讯元宝 | longyan-balcony-window-best | 龙岩封阳台哪家好？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-yuanbao-longyan-balcony-window-best.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-yuanbao-longyan-balcony-window-best.png |
| DeepSeek | longyan-system-window-recommend | 龙岩系统门窗推荐几家？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-deepseek-longyan-system-window-recommend.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-deepseek-longyan-system-window-recommend.png |
| DeepSeek | longyan-system-window-professional-store | 龙岩系统门窗哪家门店比较专业？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-deepseek-longyan-system-window-professional-store.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-deepseek-longyan-system-window-professional-store.png |
| DeepSeek | longyan-balcony-window-professional-store | 龙岩封阳台哪家门店比较专业？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-deepseek-longyan-balcony-window-professional-store.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-deepseek-longyan-balcony-window-professional-store.png |
| DeepSeek | high-rise-balcony-selection | 高层住宅封阳台怎么选？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-deepseek-high-rise-balcony-selection.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-deepseek-high-rise-balcony-selection.png |
| DeepSeek | longyan-balcony-window-best | 龙岩封阳台哪家好？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-deepseek-longyan-balcony-window-best.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-deepseek-longyan-balcony-window-best.png |
| 通义千问 | longyan-system-window-recommend | 龙岩系统门窗推荐几家？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-qianwen-longyan-system-window-recommend.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-qianwen-longyan-system-window-recommend.png |
| 通义千问 | longyan-system-window-professional-store | 龙岩系统门窗哪家门店比较专业？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-qianwen-longyan-system-window-professional-store.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-qianwen-longyan-system-window-professional-store.png |
| 通义千问 | longyan-balcony-window-professional-store | 龙岩封阳台哪家门店比较专业？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-qianwen-longyan-balcony-window-professional-store.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-qianwen-longyan-balcony-window-professional-store.png |
| 通义千问 | high-rise-balcony-selection | 高层住宅封阳台怎么选？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-qianwen-high-rise-balcony-selection.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-qianwen-high-rise-balcony-selection.png |
| 通义千问 | longyan-balcony-window-best | 龙岩封阳台哪家好？ | evidence-answers/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-qianwen-longyan-balcony-window-best.txt | evidence-screenshots/e3-natural-no-brand-20260824/e3-20260824-qianwen-longyan-balcony-window-best.png |

## 评分规则

- 干净正向：回答必须明确出现完整品牌名「禄城精密门窗」，且提示词未点名该品牌、未带目标 URL。
- 仅出现龙岩六扇门、六扇门、芬德六扇、代理商或厂家主体，不能算干净正向，只能记为 related-entity signal。
- 仅出现品牌变体，不能算干净正向，除非同时出现完整品牌名。
- 出现未核验强表述、主体混淆或编造来源，即使出现品牌名也要失败或进入人工复核。
- 同一自然问法至少 2/4 平台干净正向且无风险，才可写为弱 L4 观察；仍不能写成稳定推荐。

## 跑完后判断

- 若 same question clean positives >= 2 platforms and unsafe rows = 0：Record as L4-weak-needs-repeat; repeat Day+3/Day+7 before client-facing claim.
- 若 only related entities or brand variants appear：Strengthen entity relationship pages and official-source wording; do not claim natural recommendation.
- 若 no clean positives：Return to source distribution and question-answer evidence cards before rerunning natural category tests.
- 若 unsafe overclaims or entity confusion appear：Treat as risk remediation item before any promotion, even if the brand appears.

## 下一问

是否授权执行 E3 自然无品牌本地类目复测？精确授权句：允许执行 E3 自然无品牌本地类目复测