{ "schemaVersion": "0.1", "id": "public-search-discovery-d1-evidence-gate-20260818", "generatedAt": "2026-08-18T04:53:54+08:00", "status": "d1-evidence-gate-completed-no-positive-discovery", "purpose": "Evidence gate for the 2026-08-19 D1 public-search discovery run. It verifies whether the D1 rows have screenshots, timestamps, operator attribution, exact/canonical target URL evidence, rank and safe snippet review before any search-discovery promotion.", "targetArticle": { "articleId": "window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo", "title": "买门窗不踩坑：从行业稿到可验证验收清单", "url": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo.html" }, "run": { "runId": "d1-public-search-retest", "targetDate": "2026-08-19", "sourceExecutionPack": "/data/public-search-discovery-d1-execution-pack-20260818.json", "sourceTemplate": "/data/public-search-discovery-retest-results-template-20260818.json" }, "summary": { "totalRows": 25, "notRunRows": 0, "blockedRows": 15, "validNonPositiveRows": 10, "positiveS2Rows": 0, "positiveS3Rows": 0, "invalidRows": 0, "rowsWithScreenshot": 25, "canPromoteSearchDiscoveryS2": false, "canPromoteSearchDiscoveryS3": false, "canClaimAiAdoption": false, "canClaimNaturalRecommendation": false, "canClaimModelCognitionChanged": false, "canClaimPaidPublishingOutcome": false, "currentInterpretation": "D1 rows are fully recorded: 10 valid non-positive rows, 15 blocked rows, 0 S2/S3 positive candidates. Keep search indexing, AI adoption, natural recommendation and paid outcome unproven." }, "proofGates": [ { "gateId": "d1-g1-all-rows-accounted", "status": "passed", "requirement": "Every D1 row must be recorded as tested-not-found, exact/canonical found, blocked, ambiguous, or another allowed tested state." }, { "gateId": "d1-g2-screenshot-timestamp-operator", "status": "passed", "requirement": "Every tested D1 row must have screenshot evidence, queryTime and recordedBy." }, { "gateId": "d1-g3-search-discovery-s2", "status": "not-satisfied", "requirement": "At least one D1 row must show exact target URL or canonical equivalent with observed title, snippet, rank, timestamp and screenshot." }, { "gateId": "d1-g4-safe-snippet-s3", "status": "not-satisfied", "requirement": "At least one positive D1 row must pass safe snippet/boundary review." }, { "gateId": "d1-g5-ai-adoption-boundary", "status": "separate-ai-batch-required", "requirement": "AI adoption requires separate AI platform raw answer and screenshot evidence; D1 public-search rows alone cannot prove it." } ], "rowFindings": [ { "rowId": "psd-d1-google-q01", "searchSurface": "google", "searchSurfaceLabel": "Google", "query": "site:lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo.html", "resultStatus": "blocked-captcha-or-consent", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-google-q01.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T03:27:30+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "blocked" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-google-q02", "searchSurface": "google", "searchSurfaceLabel": "Google", "query": "\"window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo\"", "resultStatus": "blocked-captcha-or-consent", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-google-q02.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T03:37:14+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "blocked" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-google-q03", "searchSurface": "google", "searchSurfaceLabel": "Google", "query": "\"买门窗怎么避免踩坑\" \"lucheng-geo.pages.dev\"", "resultStatus": "blocked-captcha-or-consent", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-google-q03.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:21:02+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "blocked" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-google-q04", "searchSurface": "google", "searchSurfaceLabel": "Google", "query": "site:lucheng-geo.pages.dev \"买门窗怎么避免踩坑\"", "resultStatus": "blocked-captcha-or-consent", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-google-q04.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:31:00+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "blocked" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-google-q05", "searchSurface": "google", "searchSurfaceLabel": "Google", "query": "\"https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo.html\"", "resultStatus": "blocked-captcha-or-consent", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-google-q05.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:31:49+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "blocked" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-bing-q01", "searchSurface": "bing", "searchSurfaceLabel": "Bing", "query": "site:lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo.html", "resultStatus": "ambiguous-result", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-bing-q01.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T03:44:20+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "tested-non-positive-valid" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-bing-q02", "searchSurface": "bing", "searchSurfaceLabel": "Bing", "query": "\"window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo\"", "resultStatus": "tested-not-found", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-bing-q02.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:11:55+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "tested-non-positive-valid" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-bing-q03", "searchSurface": "bing", "searchSurfaceLabel": "Bing", "query": "\"买门窗怎么避免踩坑\" \"lucheng-geo.pages.dev\"", "resultStatus": "tested-not-found", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-bing-q03.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:12:07+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "tested-non-positive-valid" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-bing-q04", "searchSurface": "bing", "searchSurfaceLabel": "Bing", "query": "site:lucheng-geo.pages.dev \"买门窗怎么避免踩坑\"", "resultStatus": "tested-not-found", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-bing-q04.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:24:58+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "tested-non-positive-valid" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-bing-q05", "searchSurface": "bing", "searchSurfaceLabel": "Bing", "query": "\"https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo.html\"", "resultStatus": "tested-not-found", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-bing-q05.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:25:31+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "tested-non-positive-valid" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-baidu-q01", "searchSurface": "baidu", "searchSurfaceLabel": "百度", "query": "site:lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo.html", "resultStatus": "blocked-captcha-or-consent", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-baidu-q01.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T03:45:00+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "blocked" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-baidu-q02", "searchSurface": "baidu", "searchSurfaceLabel": "百度", "query": "\"window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo\"", "resultStatus": "blocked-captcha-or-consent", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-baidu-q02.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:27:40+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "blocked" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-baidu-q03", "searchSurface": "baidu", "searchSurfaceLabel": "百度", "query": "\"买门窗怎么避免踩坑\" \"lucheng-geo.pages.dev\"", "resultStatus": "blocked-captcha-or-consent", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-baidu-q03.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:28:10+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "blocked" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-baidu-q04", "searchSurface": "baidu", "searchSurfaceLabel": "百度", "query": "site:lucheng-geo.pages.dev \"买门窗怎么避免踩坑\"", "resultStatus": "blocked-captcha-or-consent", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-baidu-q04.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:32:38+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "blocked" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-baidu-q05", "searchSurface": "baidu", "searchSurfaceLabel": "百度", "query": "\"https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo.html\"", "resultStatus": "blocked-captcha-or-consent", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-baidu-q05.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:33:09+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "blocked" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-sogou-q01", "searchSurface": "sogou", "searchSurfaceLabel": "搜狗", "query": "site:lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo.html", "resultStatus": "blocked-captcha-or-consent", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-sogou-q01.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T03:45:24+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "blocked" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-sogou-q02", "searchSurface": "sogou", "searchSurfaceLabel": "搜狗", "query": "\"window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo\"", "resultStatus": "blocked-captcha-or-consent", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-sogou-q02.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:33:38+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "blocked" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-sogou-q03", "searchSurface": "sogou", "searchSurfaceLabel": "搜狗", "query": "\"买门窗怎么避免踩坑\" \"lucheng-geo.pages.dev\"", "resultStatus": "blocked-captcha-or-consent", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-sogou-q03.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:34:27+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "blocked" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-sogou-q04", "searchSurface": "sogou", "searchSurfaceLabel": "搜狗", "query": "site:lucheng-geo.pages.dev \"买门窗怎么避免踩坑\"", "resultStatus": "blocked-captcha-or-consent", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-sogou-q04.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:35:18+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "blocked" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-sogou-q05", "searchSurface": "sogou", "searchSurfaceLabel": "搜狗", "query": "\"https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo.html\"", "resultStatus": "blocked-captcha-or-consent", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-sogou-q05.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:36:07+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "blocked" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-so360-q01", "searchSurface": "so360", "searchSurfaceLabel": "360 搜索", "query": "site:lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo.html", "resultStatus": "tested-not-found", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-so360-q01.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T03:48:06+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "tested-non-positive-valid" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-so360-q02", "searchSurface": "so360", "searchSurfaceLabel": "360 搜索", "query": "\"window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo\"", "resultStatus": "tested-not-found", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-so360-q02.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:12:27+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "tested-non-positive-valid" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-so360-q03", "searchSurface": "so360", "searchSurfaceLabel": "360 搜索", "query": "\"买门窗怎么避免踩坑\" \"lucheng-geo.pages.dev\"", "resultStatus": "tested-not-found", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-so360-q03.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:12:56+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "tested-non-positive-valid" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-so360-q04", "searchSurface": "so360", "searchSurfaceLabel": "360 搜索", "query": "site:lucheng-geo.pages.dev \"买门窗怎么避免踩坑\"", "resultStatus": "tested-not-found", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-so360-q04.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:26:00+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "tested-non-positive-valid" }, { "rowId": "psd-d1-so360-q05", "searchSurface": "so360", "searchSurfaceLabel": "360 搜索", "query": "\"https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/window-buying-pitfall-acceptance-checklist-geo.html\"", "resultStatus": "tested-not-found", "resultClassification": "S0-not-observed", "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/public-search-discovery-retest-20260818/psd-d1-so360-q05.png", "screenshotExists": true, "queryTime": "2026-08-18T04:27:03+08:00", "recordedBy": "codex-headless-chrome", "observedResultUrl": "", "rankPosition": "", "snippetBoundaryStatus": "not-evaluated", "missingRequiredForTested": [], "missingRequiredForPositive": [], "rowGate": "tested-non-positive-valid" } ], "nextActions": [ "Resolve invalidRows first if any.", "If S2/S3 is passed, update only search-discovery records; do not claim AI adoption.", "If no positive row appears, keep the target article at crawlable-not-indexed / searchDiscovery not-observed." ], "hardBoundaries": [ "This D1 gate evaluates public search discovery only.", "It cannot prove AI platform adoption, model training ingestion, stable natural recommendation or paid publishing conversion.", "A not-run row is not evidence.", "A not-found row requires screenshot evidence and timestamp; otherwise it is only an unverified assertion." ] }