{ "schemaVersion": "0.1", "id": "objective-completion-audit-20260817", "auditedAt": "2026-08-17T22:23:47+08:00", "productionUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev", "sourceFiles": { "currentProjectProgress": "data/current-project-progress-20260817.json", "aiVisibilityLadder": "data/lucheng-ai-visibility-evidence-ladder-20260817.json", "naturalRetestResults": "data/local-category-natural-retest-results-20260817.json", "firstPaidCommercialGate": "data/first-paid-pilot-commercial-gate-20260817.json", "readinessEngineRetestResults": "data/first-paid-pilot-readiness-engine-ai-retest-results-20260817.json", "publicLiveCheck": "data/cloudflare-pages-public-live-check-20260817-readiness-engine-result-ingestion.json", "localLiveCheck": "data/gray-local-live-check-20260817-readiness-engine-result-ingestion.json", "outputJson": "data/objective-completion-audit-20260817.json", "outputMd": "docs/OBJECTIVE_COMPLETION_AUDIT_20260817.md", "outputHtml": "reports/objective-completion-audit-20260817.html" }, "verdict": "not-complete", "canMarkGoalComplete": false, "averageScore": 44, "summary": { "publicSiteOnline": true, "corePagesCrawlable": true, "somePlatformsDirectUrlRead": true, "allFourPlatformsDirectUrlRead": false, "currentNaturalCategoryRecommendation": false, "stableAiRecommendation": false, "searchIndexed": false, "modelTrainingAbsorption": false, "sellOutcomePromise": false, "readinessEngineRowsTested": 0, "readinessEngineRowsTotal": 8 }, "oneLineConclusion": "项目已完成公开站点和方法论样板，但原始目标中的 AI 自然推荐、搜索收录、训练吸收、客户充值发文商业闭环均未证明，不能标记目标完成。", "rows": [ { "id": "REQ-01", "requirement": "查阅并吸收 IMA / GEO / 门窗建材知识，形成站点和内容方法论", "status": "substantially-proven-for-internal-method", "score": 82, "evidenceSummary": "已形成门窗建材样板内容、证据分级、问题池、AI 可读页面合同、发布/监测/诊断服务结构；IMA 和订阅资料被当作内部方法来源，不直接作为公开证据。", "proofGap": "仍需继续把私有知识库材料转化为可披露证据摘要，不能公开引用未授权全文。", "nextAction": "后续只把 IMA 用于内部内容结构和证据线索；公开页面继续标注来源、证据缺口和建议补充。", "evidenceFiles": [ "data/current-project-progress-20260817.json", "data/lucheng-ai-visibility-evidence-ladder-20260817.json" ] }, { "id": "REQ-02", "requirement": "从技术规律构建 AI 抓取友好的门户/资讯站", "status": "proven-public-crawlability", "score": 90, "evidenceSummary": "Cloudflare Pages 生产站已上线；生产 full check 176/176 入口通过；站点包含 robots、sitemap、RSS、llms.txt、AI crawl index、结构化 HTML 报告和 JSON 数据。", "proofGap": "公开可抓取不等于搜索已索引，也不等于 AI 已主动采用。", "nextAction": "继续保留 sitemap/feed/llms/AI crawl index；每次新增报告后执行本地和生产 full check。", "evidenceFiles": [ "data/cloudflare-pages-public-live-check-20260817-readiness-engine-result-ingestion.json", "data/gray-local-live-check-20260817-readiness-engine-result-ingestion.json", "data/current-project-progress-20260817.json" ] }, { "id": "REQ-03", "requirement": "以门窗建材 / 禄城精密门窗作为样板推进", "status": "sample-site-online-not-success-case", "score": 72, "evidenceSummary": "禄城样板站已公开；当前证据阶梯结论：公开站点可抓取和部分 direct-url 读取已经成立；搜索发现、自然无品牌推荐、跨时间稳定推荐仍未证明。当前只能把禄城精密门窗表述为“待核验本地候选入口”，不能表述为“已被四大 AI 平台自然推荐”。", "proofGap": "样板不等于客户成功案例；自然类目问法尚未明确推荐“禄城精密门窗”。", "nextAction": "继续补安装 SOP、节点照片、验收单样张、售后边界、授权案例，并执行 Day1/Day3/Day7 复测。", "evidenceFiles": [ "data/lucheng-ai-visibility-evidence-ladder-20260817.json", "data/local-category-natural-retest-results-20260817.json", "data/current-project-progress-20260817.json" ] }, { "id": "REQ-04", "requirement": "验证豆包、腾讯元宝、DeepSeek、通义千问能否读取当前站点内容", "status": "partially-proven-direct-url", "score": 58, "evidenceSummary": "当前进度记录：站点公开可抓取已经成立；豆包、元宝、DeepSeek 已出现 direct-url 读取迹象；实体消歧页在豆包、元宝、DeepSeek 上直链可读，千问未观察到有效回答；2026-08-17 18:10 的自然无品牌问法复测中，豆包、DeepSeek、元宝有回答但均未明确出现“禄城精密门窗”，豆包只出现“芬德六扇/六扇门”相关主体信号，千问未捕获回答正文；“龙岩封阳台哪家门店比较专业？”候选证据页已按最新复测补强，并已生成 Day1/Day3/Day7 复测包、外部分发执行包、只读授权包、分发台账实例和 AI 可见性证据分级看板；仍不能宣称 AI 已自然推荐或稳定推荐禄城。", "proofGap": "四平台全量 direct-url 读取未证明；readiness engine 新批次仍为 0/8 真实回答。", "nextAction": "执行 readiness engine 8 条 direct-url 测试，保存原始回答和截图，再用录入脚本重算结果。", "evidenceFiles": [ "data/current-project-progress-20260817.json", "data/first-paid-pilot-readiness-engine-ai-retest-results-20260817.json" ] }, { "id": "REQ-05", "requirement": "验证自然无品牌问法下是否会推荐目标品牌", "status": "not-achieved", "score": 0, "evidenceSummary": "本轮自然无品牌问法在豆包、DeepSeek、元宝取得回答，但均未明确推荐“禄城精密门窗”；豆包只出现“芬德六扇/六扇门”相关实体信号，不能算目标品牌成功推荐；千问未捕获回答正文。", "proofGap": "没有 L4 自然推荐证据；不能对外写“已被四大 AI 平台推荐”。", "nextAction": "按同一问题在 Day1/Day3/Day7 复测，记录平台、时间、问题、原始回答、截图和是否出现完整目标品牌。", "evidenceFiles": [ "data/local-category-natural-retest-results-20260817.json", "data/lucheng-ai-visibility-evidence-ladder-20260817.json" ] }, { "id": "REQ-06", "requirement": "验证搜索发现 / AI 搜索引用 / 外部分发是否形成发现面", "status": "not-proven-for-target-pages", "score": 20, "evidenceSummary": "公开搜索发现快照仍未观察到目标 pages.dev 候选页命中，但观察到 Winsmo 官网、凤凰网、红商网、中国家居网、OFweek、知乎等品牌信源候选。", "proofGap": "L3 自有目标页搜索发现未达成；外部信源仍需逐条审核来源质量、可读性、授权和事实边界。", "nextAction": "先做只读来源路线审核；不投稿、不扣费、不改官网，除非用户单独授权。", "evidenceFiles": [ "data/current-project-progress-20260817.json", "data/lucheng-ai-visibility-evidence-ladder-20260817.json" ] }, { "id": "REQ-07", "requirement": "验证客户充值付费发文盈利模式", "status": "paid-publishing-closed-diagnostic-pilot-possible", "score": 38, "evidenceSummary": "当前可以准备首单“小额诊断/监测 pilot”，但不能开放自助充值发文，也不能销售 AI 收录、推荐、排名或模型认知改变承诺。", "proofGap": "真实客户充值、合同、退款、扣费、发布、AI 结果报告、复购均未验证。", "nextAction": "只卖“诊断/监测 pilot”，且必须先签服务确认单；继续关闭自助充值发文。", "evidenceFiles": [ "data/first-paid-pilot-commercial-gate-20260817.json", "data/current-project-progress-20260817.json" ] }, { "id": "REQ-08", "requirement": "建立可验证的客户结果交付闭环", "status": "workflow-ready-results-missing", "score": 45, "evidenceSummary": "readiness engine 复测结果状态：not-executed；已测试 0/8；边界通过 0/8。录入/评分脚本已经建立。", "proofGap": "当前只有操作台和评分器，没有 8 条真实平台回答。", "nextAction": "执行 8 条真实平台复测；结果页只按原始回答和截图升级证据等级。", "evidenceFiles": [ "data/first-paid-pilot-readiness-engine-ai-retest-results-20260817.json" ] }, { "id": "REQ-09", "requirement": "评估是否可以宣称改变 AI 模型认知 / 影响搜索结果", "status": "not-claimable", "score": 0, "evidenceSummary": "当前证据只能支持公开可抓取、部分 direct-url 读取、诊断服务形态；不能证明训练吸收、模型认知改变、排名变化或稳定推荐。", "proofGap": "缺长期、多平台、无品牌提示、跨时间、带来源引用的 L4/L5 稳定复现证据；即使以后观察到，也不能保证未来稳定。", "nextAction": "对外产品口径固定为证据诊断、内容结构、分发执行和 AI 可见性监测。", "evidenceFiles": [ "data/current-project-progress-20260817.json", "data/lucheng-ai-visibility-evidence-ladder-20260817.json" ] }, { "id": "REQ-10", "requirement": "判断原始创业项目是否可以进入收费推广", "status": "not-ready-for-outcome-sales", "score": 36, "evidenceSummary": "可以继续推进禄城样板和首单小额诊断 pilot；不能销售“发文后 AI 推荐品牌”的结果承诺。", "proofGap": "缺真实客户市场验证、自然推荐证据、搜索发现证据和商业转化证据。", "nextAction": "先完成 8 条 readiness engine 复测和 Day1/Day3/Day7 自然问法复测，再决定是否寻找首单诊断客户。", "evidenceFiles": [ "data/current-project-progress-20260817.json", "data/first-paid-pilot-commercial-gate-20260817.json", "data/first-paid-pilot-readiness-engine-ai-retest-results-20260817.json" ] } ], "nextBestActions": [ "执行 readiness engine 8 条四平台 direct-url 复测并录入原始回答。", "按 Day1/Day3/Day7 执行“龙岩封阳台哪家门店比较专业？”自然问法复测。", "补齐禄城安装 SOP、节点照片、验收单样张、售后边界和案例授权。", "只读审核外部信源路线，不提交、不付费、不改官网，除非另有明确授权。", "首单只允许诊断/监测 pilot，不开放自助充值发文。" ], "hardBoundaries": [ "Do not claim AI indexing, search ranking, model training absorption, stable recommendation, customer conversion or paid publishing outcome.", "Public crawlability and direct-url reading are not natural recommendation evidence.", "Historical channel samples cannot be sold as current customer success.", "This audit does not authorize browser AI testing, external submissions, official-site edits, DNS changes, D1/KV/Workers creation, payments or customer outreach." ] }