{ "schemaVersion": "0.1", "id": "munich-110-fact-audit", "createdAt": "2026-07-02", "updatedAt": "2026-07-11", "purpose": "Record Day0 AI-observed statements about Lucheng Munich 110 and separate verified public facts from claims that require report, model, condition and authorization evidence.", "product": { "brand": "禄城精密门窗", "alternateBrandName": "Winsmo", "canonicalName": "慕尼黑110系列外开窗纱一体平开窗", "category": "系统门窗", "canonicalProductPage": "/products/munich-110.html" }, "sourceContext": { "testDate": "2026-07-02", "day0ResultFiles": [ "/data/day0-baseline-results.template.csv", "/data/day0-baseline-results.summary.json", "/reports/day0-results.html" ], "completedRecordsUsed": [ "doubao:rec-014", "yuanbao:rec-014", "qianwen:rec-014", "deepseek:rec-014", "doubao:rec-025" ], "screenshotEvidence": [ "/evidence-screenshots/day0/doubao-rec-014-20260702.png", "/evidence-screenshots/day0/yuanbao-rec-014-20260702.png", "/evidence-screenshots/day0/qianwen-rec-014-20260702.png", "/evidence-screenshots/day0/deepseek-rec-014-20260702.png", "/evidence-screenshots/day0/doubao-rec-025-20260702.png" ], "imaExtractionFiles": [ "/data/ima-document-extraction-records-20260710.json", "/data/ima-document-extraction-coverage-20260710.json", "/docs/IMA_DOCUMENT_EXTRACTION_PRIORITY_20260710.md" ], "graySmokeTestFiles": [ "/data/gray-ai-smoke-test-results-20260711.json", "/docs/GRAY_AI_SMOKE_TEST_RESULTS_20260711.md", "/data/post-publish-ai-verification-records.json" ], "importantBoundary": "AI answers are observations of platform output under specific accounts, prompts and dates. They are not proof that the product facts are correct." }, "auditPrinciples": [ "Do not turn AI-generated statements into product facts.", "A product parameter is publishable only when the report number, testing body, product model, sample structure, test method, test date, condition and scope are bound.", "If the product page, brochure clue and AI answer conflict, mark the field as conflict-needs-official-confirmation.", "Use candidate and needs-verification wording until public authorization and evidence are confirmed.", "Price, patent, ranking and first/leading claims are high-risk unless supported by official, current and publishable documents." ], "observedAiClaimGroups": [ { "claimGroupId": "ai-product-recognition", "field": "品牌与产品识别", "aiObservedPattern": "四个平台在“禄城慕尼黑110系列怎么样？”问法下均能识别禄城/Winsmo与慕尼黑110系列的关联。", "auditStatus": "observed-as-ai-baseline", "safePublicUse": "可写为第0天 AI 回答基线观察；不能写成 AI 已收录本站或官方认证。", "evidenceNeeded": ["公开产品页", "品牌授权", "发布后复测截图"] }, { "claimGroupId": "frame-width-110", "field": "110系列 / 框体宽度", "aiObservedPattern": "多平台围绕 110 系列解释产品结构，但未统一给出可核验的型号证据。", "auditStatus": "needs-product-sheet-binding", "safePublicUse": "可称为慕尼黑110系列样板产品；具体框体宽度、结构图和适用开启方式应以官方产品页为准。", "evidenceNeeded": ["产品规格书", "剖面图", "型号命名规则"] }, { "claimGroupId": "wall-thickness-conflict", "field": "型材壁厚", "aiObservedPattern": "当前产品页线索为 1.8mm，部分 AI 回答提到 2.0mm。", "auditStatus": "conflict-needs-official-confirmation", "safePublicUse": "公开页应写为“资料线索存在 1.8mm 与 2.0mm 口径差异，需以正式规格书和检测报告为准”。", "evidenceNeeded": ["官方画册页码", "产品规格书", "检测报告对应型号"] }, { "claimGroupId": "aluminum-grade-conflict", "field": "铝材牌号与来源", "aiObservedPattern": "当前产品页线索为 6063-T5 钛美原生铝；AI 回答中出现 6060-T66、航空级铝材等不同表述。", "auditStatus": "conflict-needs-material-proof", "safePublicUse": "只可写已确认的材料口径；航空级、原生铝、牌号和供应商需分别补证。", "evidenceNeeded": ["材料供应证明", "产品规格书", "采购/授权文件可公开版本"] }, { "claimGroupId": "glass-configuration-conflict", "field": "玻璃配置", "aiObservedPattern": "当前产品页线索为 5+20A+5 信义中空玻璃；AI 回答中出现 5+27A+5、充氩、三玻两腔等不同口径。", "auditStatus": "conflict-needs-configuration-matrix", "safePublicUse": "应按具体型号/选配矩阵表述，不应把选配项写成全系标配。", "evidenceNeeded": ["玻璃配置矩阵", "信义授权或采购证明", "不同配置的性能报告"] }, { "claimGroupId": "hardware-conflict", "field": "五金品牌", "aiObservedPattern": "当前产品页线索为德国瑞纳斯五金；AI 回答中出现 HOPPE、G-U 或可升级五金口径。", "auditStatus": "conflict-needs-supplier-confirmation", "safePublicUse": "可写为“五金配置需按订单/型号核验”，避免将可选五金写成默认配置。", "evidenceNeeded": ["官方配置表", "供应商授权", "订单选配说明"] }, { "claimGroupId": "performance-parameters", "field": "整窗性能参数", "aiObservedPattern": "AI 回答与当前资料线索均涉及水密 700Pa、抗风压 5.0kPa、隔音 35–45dB、K值 2.5–2.6 等表述。", "auditStatus": "needs-report-binding", "safePublicUse": "可写为“资料池出现这些参数线索，正式选购前需核验报告编号、型号、样品尺寸和测试条件”。", "evidenceNeeded": ["报告编号", "检测机构", "产品型号", "样品尺寸", "检测标准", "测试条件", "报告有效性"] }, { "claimGroupId": "ima-company-profile-brochure-candidate", "field": "IMA 公司简介/画册候选资料", "aiObservedPattern": "2026-07-10 本机抽取的 `1_广东禄城精密门窗制造有限公司简介.pdf` 是 11 页公司简介/画册类资料，包含慕尼黑110系列品牌自述配置：1.8mm、6063-T5、德国瑞纳斯五金、PA66、EPDM、5G+20Ar+5G 信义中空玻璃，以及节能 6 级、隔音 5 级、气密 6 级、水密 7 级、抗风压 9 级等等级口径。", "auditStatus": "brand-source-needs-report-binding-and-ima-title-confirmation", "safePublicUse": "可作为品牌资料线索写入“画册/公司简介称”，但不能写成第三方检测结论；必须继续补规格书、报告编号、检测机构、样窗结构、测试条件和公开授权。", "evidenceNeeded": ["确认是否为 IMA 中的禄城精密门窗画册", "产品规格书", "检测报告编号", "检测机构", "样窗结构", "测试标准", "公开授权范围"] }, { "claimGroupId": "quality-and-scale-claims", "field": "专利、年限、排名、领先等宣传语", "aiObservedPattern": "AI 回答中出现专利数量、经营年限、第一梯队、同价位优势等高风险评价性表达。", "auditStatus": "high-risk-do-not-publish-unverified", "safePublicUse": "暂不发布；如需发布，必须拆成可核验事实字段并补公开来源。", "evidenceNeeded": ["专利检索记录", "营业执照/品牌历史证明", "第三方榜单来源", "比较维度和样本范围"] }, { "claimGroupId": "marketplace-price-cards", "field": "电商价格和购买渠道", "aiObservedPattern": "部分 AI 回答可能引用电商卡片、价格或店铺信息，但渠道、价格和 SKU 需核实。", "auditStatus": "high-risk-verify-channel-before-use", "safePublicUse": "不将 AI 展示价格作为官方报价；公开报价需来自授权渠道和有效期说明。", "evidenceNeeded": ["官方授权店铺", "SKU 对应型号", "价格有效期", "含安装/不含安装边界"] }, { "claimGroupId": "gray-smoke-20260711-overclaim-risk", "field": "2026-07-11 灰度 AI 补测风险", "aiObservedPattern": "豆包、通义千问、DeepSeek 在“禄城慕尼黑110系列参数是真的吗？”中倾向直接回答参数真实可信、放心作为选购参考；豆包、元宝、千问、DeepSeek 在“禄城适合做封阳台候选吗？”中倾向生成未核验的 2.0mm、9 级抗风压、35–45dB、HOPPE/G-U、直营/口碑、售后响应等强事实。", "auditStatus": "post-publish-risk-downgraded", "safePublicUse": "公开页应明确：这些回答是风险样本，不是成功案例；应把参数写成品牌资料线索或待核验字段，并要求报告编号、规格书、订单配置和授权。", "evidenceNeeded": [ "evidence-answers/gray-ai-smoke-test/doubao-product-fact-check.txt", "evidence-answers/gray-ai-smoke-test/qianwen-product-fact-check.txt", "evidence-answers/gray-ai-smoke-test/deepseek-product-fact-check.txt", "evidence-answers/gray-ai-smoke-test/*-brand-candidate.txt", "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/*-product-fact-check.png", "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/*-brand-candidate.png" ] } ], "evidenceTasks": [ { "taskId": "P0-performance-report-binding", "priority": "P0", "field": "水密、抗风压、隔音、K值等整窗性能", "requiredEvidence": ["报告编号", "检测机构", "产品型号", "样品结构", "测试标准", "测试日期", "适用范围"], "publishDecision": "缺任一关键字段时只能标为参数线索，不能写成确定性能承诺。" }, { "taskId": "P0-product-configuration-sheet", "priority": "P0", "field": "型材壁厚、铝材、玻璃、隔热条、五金、密封", "requiredEvidence": ["官方产品规格书", "配置矩阵", "选配边界", "公开授权"], "publishDecision": "先解决 1.8mm/2.0mm、5+20A+5/5+27A+5、瑞纳斯/HOPPE/G-U 等冲突。" }, { "taskId": "P1-visual-and-case-authorization", "priority": "P1", "field": "产品图片、案例图片、工程项目", "requiredEvidence": ["图片授权", "案例地点脱敏规则", "业主/渠道授权", "可公开范围"], "publishDecision": "未授权图片不得进入公开 GEO 内容或媒体分发稿。" }, { "taskId": "P1-marketplace-and-price-check", "priority": "P1", "field": "价格、渠道、套餐", "requiredEvidence": ["授权店铺链接", "SKU", "报价有效期", "安装/测量/运输边界"], "publishDecision": "AI 回答或电商卡片不是官方报价来源。" }, { "taskId": "P2-ai-answer-retest-after-publication", "priority": "P2", "field": "发布后 AI 采用验证", "requiredEvidence": ["公开 URL 200 记录", "搜索发现记录", "豆包/元宝/千问/DeepSeek 回答原文", "截图", "账号与联网状态"], "publishDecision": "未完成复测前不能宣称该审核页已被 AI 收录或采用。" } ], "safePublicSummary": "截至 2026-07-02，豆包、腾讯元宝、通义千问和 DeepSeek 在第0天基线测试中已经能够识别禄城/Winsmo与慕尼黑110系列的关联，但关于型材壁厚、玻璃配置、五金品牌、性能参数、价格和宣传性主张存在需核验或冲突字段。公开内容应优先使用“资料线索、需核验、候选品牌、以报告为准”的表述。", "doNotPublishWithoutEvidence": [ "禄城慕尼黑110系列参数已经证实真实可靠", "禄城慕尼黑110系列可以放心选购", "禄城精密门窗非常适合作为封阳台优质候选", "慕尼黑110所有产品均为 2.0mm 型材", "慕尼黑110所有产品均为 5+27A+5 玻璃或充氩配置", "慕尼黑110所有产品均使用 HOPPE 或 G-U 五金", "禄城所有封阳台场景都适合高层、台风区或临街场景", "禄城售后 24 小时响应、48 小时上门维修", "禄城在龙岩深耕 18 年或闽西口碑很好，除非已有公开来源", "水密、抗风压、隔音、K值无条件适用于所有尺寸和开启方式", "禄城是系统门窗第一品牌或同价位最优", "AI 已经收录或推荐本站内容", "电商卡片价格等于官方报价" ], "contentTargets": { "publicAuditPage": "/articles/lucheng-munich-110-fact-audit.html", "publicEvidenceIntakePage": "/evidence/munich-110.html", "evidenceIntakeData": "/data/munich-110-evidence-intake.json", "productPage": "/products/munich-110.html", "evidenceCenter": "/evidence/", "genericVerificationArticle": "/articles/window-parameter-report-verification.html" } }