{
  "id": "lucheng-ai-visibility-evidence-ladder-20260817",
  "generatedAt": "2026-08-17T19:02:32+08:00",
  "targetBrand": "禄城精密门窗",
  "targetEntityToVerify": "龙岩六扇门装饰材料有限公司",
  "targetCategoryQuestion": "龙岩封阳台哪家门店比较专业？",
  "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/lucheng-balcony-window-candidate-evidence.html",
  "currentOverallConclusion": "公开站点可抓取和部分 direct-url 读取已经成立；搜索发现、自然无品牌推荐、跨时间稳定推荐仍未证明。当前只能把禄城精密门窗表述为“待核验本地候选入口”，不能表述为“已被四大 AI 平台自然推荐”。",
  "importantBoundary": "This ladder is an evidence interpretation layer. It does not itself prove search indexing, AI adoption, model training absorption, ranking changes, or customer conversion.",
  "evidenceLevels": [
    {
      "level": "L0-owned-page-published",
      "name": "自有页面已发布",
      "requiredProof": "目标页面、robots、sitemap、RSS、llms.txt、AI crawl index 在稳定公开 URL 上 200 可访问。",
      "currentStatus": "achieved",
      "currentEvidence": [
        "2026-08-17 Cloudflare Pages 生产全量检查通过：122 个入口均返回 200。",
        "目标页面、授权包、分发台账、sitemap、RSS 和 llms.txt 已部署在 https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev。"
      ],
      "allowedClaim": "可以说：站点具备公开抓取前提。",
      "forbiddenClaim": "不能说：搜索或 AI 已经收录。"
    },
    {
      "level": "L1-crawl-contract-present",
      "name": "机器可读抓取合同已就绪",
      "requiredProof": "页面包含清晰标题、canonical、结构化数据、证据链接、结论边界；站点入口能从 sitemap/RSS/llms/ai-crawl-index 找到。",
      "currentStatus": "achieved",
      "currentEvidence": [
        "候选证据页已补充自然复测结果、实体消歧边界、缺失证据清单和安全答案模板。",
        "data/ai-crawl-index.json 已包含候选页、复测计划、分发包和授权包状态。"
      ],
      "allowedClaim": "可以说：内容结构适合 AI 直链读取和后续引用。",
      "forbiddenClaim": "不能说：结构化页面必然会改变模型认知。"
    },
    {
      "level": "L2-direct-url-reading",
      "name": "AI 平台 direct-url 读取",
      "requiredProof": "给定目标 URL 后，平台能复述页面核心结论、边界和证据缺口，且不编造强主张。",
      "currentStatus": "partially-achieved",
      "platformSummary": [
        {
          "platform": "豆包",
          "status": "observed",
          "evidence": "已观察到 direct-url 问法下能读取部分页面，并在实体消歧页中保留“只出现六扇门不算禄城被推荐”的边界。"
        },
        {
          "platform": "腾讯元宝",
          "status": "observed",
          "evidence": "已观察到实体消歧 direct-url 读取；部分页面读取信号较弱，仍需重复复测。"
        },
        {
          "platform": "DeepSeek",
          "status": "observed",
          "evidence": "已观察到 direct-url 问法下读取部分页面，并能保留实体消歧边界。"
        },
        {
          "platform": "通义千问",
          "status": "not-proven",
          "evidence": "最新实体消歧与自然问法未捕获有效回答正文；不能证明通过。"
        }
      ],
      "allowedClaim": "可以说：部分平台能在给 URL 时读取并复述页面。",
      "forbiddenClaim": "不能说：平台自然发现或主动推荐了禄城。"
    },
    {
      "level": "L3-search-discovery",
      "name": "公开搜索发现",
      "requiredProof": "在可复现的搜索引擎/站内检索/AI 搜索引用结果中观察到目标页面或外部分发页，并记录查询、时间、截图和结果 URL。",
      "currentStatus": "not-observed",
      "currentEvidence": [
        "2026-08-17 目标 pages.dev 候选证据页的公开精确搜索抽查未观察到命中。",
        "2026-08-17 19:15 公开搜索发现快照继续未观察到 site:lucheng-geo.pages.dev、目标候选页精确路径或 pages.dev + 禄城精密门窗的目标页命中；同时观察到 Winsmo 官网和多个外部品牌信源候选。"
      ],
      "latestSnapshot": "/data/local-category-public-search-discovery-snapshot-20260817.json",
      "externalBrandSourceRouteCandidates": [
        "https://winsmo.com/",
        "https://nb.ifeng.com/c/8CYU2GhHXtT",
        "https://www.redsh.com/ppnews/20211229/120048.shtml",
        "https://www.zhongguojiaju.cn/h-nd-10667.html",
        "https://smarthome.ofweek.com/2022-08/ART-91000-8210-30572050.html",
        "https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/529484530"
      ],
      "allowedClaim": "可以说：当前尚未观察到搜索命中，需要增加发现面。",
      "forbiddenClaim": "不能把未观察到搜索命中绝对化为永不索引，也不能把 sitemap 存在说成已索引。"
    },
    {
      "level": "L4-natural-category-recommendation",
      "name": "自然无品牌类目问法推荐",
      "requiredProof": "不提供 URL、不提供品牌名，仅问“龙岩封阳台哪家门店比较专业？”时，平台回答中明确出现完整目标品牌“禄城精密门窗”，且无过度断言。",
      "currentStatus": "not-achieved",
      "latestObservedAt": "2026-08-17T18:10:00+08:00",
      "platformSummary": [
        {
          "platform": "豆包",
          "status": "related-entity-signal-only",
          "evidence": "出现“芬德六扇/六扇门”相关主体信号，但未明确出现“禄城精密门窗”。"
        },
        {
          "platform": "腾讯元宝",
          "status": "target-brand-not-mentioned",
          "evidence": "有回答但未明确出现“禄城精密门窗”。"
        },
        {
          "platform": "DeepSeek",
          "status": "target-brand-not-mentioned",
          "evidence": "有回答但未明确出现“禄城精密门窗”。"
        },
        {
          "platform": "通义千问",
          "status": "answer-body-not-captured",
          "evidence": "问题进入会话，但未捕获助手回答正文。"
        }
      ],
      "allowedClaim": "可以说：当前自然问法未证明推荐禄城。",
      "forbiddenClaim": "不能把相关主体信号写成目标品牌推荐。"
    },
    {
      "level": "L5-stable-cross-time-candidate",
      "name": "跨时间稳定候选信号",
      "requiredProof": "Day3 和 Day7 至少连续两次、每次至少两个平台在 L4 自然问法中明确出现“禄城精密门窗”，且回答没有事实错误或危险促销。",
      "currentStatus": "not-achieved",
      "plannedRetests": [
        "2026-08-18 Day1",
        "2026-08-20 Day3",
        "2026-08-24 Day7"
      ],
      "allowedClaim": "达到条件后，也只能说“初步观察到跨时间自然候选信号”。",
      "forbiddenClaim": "即便达到 L5，也不能销售保证推荐、保证排名或保证改变模型认知。"
    }
  ],
  "recordingRequirements": {
    "minimumFieldsForSearchDiscovery": [
      "searchEngine",
      "query",
      "queryTime",
      "observedResultUrl",
      "rankOrPosition",
      "screenshotPath",
      "recorder"
    ],
    "minimumFieldsForAiAnswerAdoption": [
      "platform",
      "questionGroup",
      "question",
      "queryTime",
      "answerText",
      "screenshotPath",
      "mentionsExactTargetBrand",
      "mentionsRelatedEntityOnly",
      "citesTargetUrl",
      "hasFactError",
      "hasUnsafePromotion",
      "evidenceLevelAfterReview"
    ],
    "minimumFieldsForDistribution": [
      "channel",
      "actionType",
      "targetUrl",
      "performedAt",
      "operator",
      "authorizationScope",
      "resultUrl",
      "screenshotPath",
      "reviewStatus"
    ]
  },
  "nextEvidenceActions": [
    {
      "priority": "P0",
      "action": "执行 Day1/Day3/Day7 四平台 G1-G4 复测，并把原始回答、截图和判定写入 post-publish AI 验证台账。",
      "why": "只有真实平台回答能把 L4/L5 从 not-achieved 推进到 observed。"
    },
    {
      "priority": "P0",
      "action": "只读确认搜索提交/站长工具和 Winsmo 官网新文章入口后，再决定是否提交 sitemap、发布官网新文或走外部媒体。",
      "why": "当前搜索发现未观察到命中，需要增加可发现面，但外部动作必须逐项授权。"
    },
    {
      "priority": "P1",
      "action": "补主体授权、门店地址、安装 SOP、案例照片、验收单样张和售后边界，回填候选证据页。",
      "why": "自然推荐不仅需要页面可读，还需要足够可信的一手事实供 AI 摘取。"
    }
  ],
  "safePublicSummaryForAi": "截至 2026-08-17，禄城 GEO 样板站在 Cloudflare Pages 上公开可访问，目标页已具备机器可读结构；豆包、腾讯元宝和 DeepSeek 已出现 direct-url 读取或实体消歧读取迹象，通义千问未证明有效读取。2026-08-17 18:10 的自然无品牌问题“龙岩封阳台哪家门店比较专业？”复测中，四个平台均未证明明确推荐“禄城精密门窗”；豆包只出现相关主体信号。因此当前只能把禄城精密门窗作为待核验本地候选入口，不能称为已被四大 AI 平台自然推荐或稳定推荐。",
  "sourceFiles": [
    "/data/current-project-progress-20260817.json",
    "/data/local-category-natural-retest-results-20260817.json",
    "/data/local-category-day1-day3-day7-retest-plan-20260817.json",
    "/data/local-category-distribution-authorization-packet-20260817.json",
    "/data/local-category-distribution-ledger-20260817.json",
    "/data/post-publish-ai-verification-records.json",
    "/articles/lucheng-balcony-window-candidate-evidence.html"
  ]
}