{
  "schemaVersion": "0.1",
  "id": "gray-ai-smoke-test-results-20260711",
  "generatedAt": "2026-08-17T02:29:10.194Z",
  "timezone": "Asia/Shanghai",
  "smokeTest": "/data/gray-ai-smoke-test-20260708.json",
  "records": "/data/post-publish-ai-verification-records.json",
  "publicGates": "/data/gray-public-gates-latest.json",
  "baseUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev",
  "publicCrawlabilityState": {
    "status": "passed",
    "checkedAt": "2026-08-17T02:06:35.257Z",
    "passedSteps": 6,
    "failedSteps": 0,
    "boundary": "Public gate proves crawlability for tested URL set only, not AI training absorption or stable recommendation."
  },
  "decision": {
    "status": "direct-url-read-only",
    "oneLine": "灰度站已观察到3/4 平台直接 URL 读取；系统门窗泛问法暂未自然推荐禄城。",
    "canClaimPublicCrawlable": true,
    "canClaimDirectUrlRead": true,
    "canClaimFourPlatformDirectUrlRead": false,
    "canClaimGenericRecommendation": false,
    "canClaimStableRecommendation": false,
    "canSellOutcomePromise": false
  },
  "summary": {
    "totalSmokeRows": 24,
    "testedRows": 24,
    "untestedRows": 0,
    "l2Rows": 5,
    "l3Rows": 1,
    "l4Rows": 0,
    "l5Rows": 0,
    "l4OrL5Rows": 0,
    "riskRows": 11,
    "directUrlPlatformsPassed": 3,
    "genericSystemBrandRowsTested": 4,
    "genericSystemBrandRowsSucceeded": 0,
    "genericBalconyBrandRowsTested": 4,
    "genericBalconyBrandRowsSucceeded": 0
  },
  "platformSummary": [
    {
      "id": "doubao",
      "totalRows": 6,
      "testedRows": 6,
      "l2Rows": 1,
      "l3Rows": 0,
      "l4Rows": 0,
      "l5Rows": 0,
      "failedRows": 5
    },
    {
      "id": "yuanbao",
      "totalRows": 6,
      "testedRows": 6,
      "l2Rows": 2,
      "l3Rows": 1,
      "l4Rows": 0,
      "l5Rows": 0,
      "failedRows": 3
    },
    {
      "id": "qianwen",
      "totalRows": 6,
      "testedRows": 6,
      "l2Rows": 0,
      "l3Rows": 0,
      "l4Rows": 0,
      "l5Rows": 0,
      "failedRows": 6
    },
    {
      "id": "deepseek",
      "totalRows": 6,
      "testedRows": 6,
      "l2Rows": 2,
      "l3Rows": 0,
      "l4Rows": 0,
      "l5Rows": 0,
      "failedRows": 4
    }
  ],
  "smokeSummary": [
    {
      "id": "url-system-brand",
      "totalRows": 4,
      "testedRows": 4,
      "l2Rows": 2,
      "l3Rows": 0,
      "l4Rows": 0,
      "l5Rows": 0,
      "failedRows": 2
    },
    {
      "id": "url-balcony-acceptance",
      "totalRows": 4,
      "testedRows": 4,
      "l2Rows": 3,
      "l3Rows": 0,
      "l4Rows": 0,
      "l5Rows": 0,
      "failedRows": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "generic-system-brand",
      "totalRows": 4,
      "testedRows": 4,
      "l2Rows": 0,
      "l3Rows": 0,
      "l4Rows": 0,
      "l5Rows": 0,
      "failedRows": 4
    },
    {
      "id": "generic-balcony-brand",
      "totalRows": 4,
      "testedRows": 4,
      "l2Rows": 0,
      "l3Rows": 0,
      "l4Rows": 0,
      "l5Rows": 0,
      "failedRows": 4
    },
    {
      "id": "brand-candidate",
      "totalRows": 4,
      "testedRows": 4,
      "l2Rows": 0,
      "l3Rows": 0,
      "l4Rows": 0,
      "l5Rows": 0,
      "failedRows": 4
    },
    {
      "id": "product-fact-check",
      "totalRows": 4,
      "testedRows": 4,
      "l2Rows": 0,
      "l3Rows": 1,
      "l4Rows": 0,
      "l5Rows": 0,
      "failedRows": 3
    }
  ],
  "rows": [
    {
      "rowId": "doubao-url-system-brand",
      "smokeId": "url-system-brand",
      "platformId": "doubao",
      "platformName": "豆包",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "direct-url-summary",
      "questionToAsk": "请只基于这个公开页面总结：https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist.html。这个页面能回答什么问题？如果无法访问，请明确说明无法访问。",
      "articleId": "system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "observed-not-adopted",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260716122329-system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist-ai-answer-adoption-doubao-direct-url-summary",
      "bestRecordStatus": "fetch-failed",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-16T19:55:00+08:00",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": false,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 0,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/pagesdev-ai-20260716/doubao-url-system-brand-blocked.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "yuanbao-url-system-brand",
      "smokeId": "url-system-brand",
      "platformId": "yuanbao",
      "platformName": "腾讯元宝",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "direct-url-summary",
      "questionToAsk": "请只基于这个公开页面总结：https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist.html。这个页面能回答什么问题？如果无法访问，请明确说明无法访问。",
      "articleId": "system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "L2-direct-url-ai-read",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260716122330-system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist-ai-answer-adoption-yuanbao-direct-url-summary",
      "bestRecordStatus": "adopted-no-citation",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-16T19:58:00+08:00",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": true,
      "mentionsArticle": true,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": true,
      "score": 65,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/pagesdev-ai-20260716/yuanbao-url-system-brand.png",
      "canClaimL2": true,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "qianwen-url-system-brand",
      "smokeId": "url-system-brand",
      "platformId": "qianwen",
      "platformName": "通义千问",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "direct-url-summary",
      "questionToAsk": "请只基于这个公开页面总结：https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist.html。这个页面能回答什么问题？如果无法访问，请明确说明无法访问。",
      "articleId": "system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "observed-not-adopted",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260716122330-system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist-ai-answer-adoption-qianwen-direct-url-summary",
      "bestRecordStatus": "not-observed",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-16T20:02:00+08:00",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": false,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 0,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/pagesdev-ai-20260716/qianwen-url-system-brand-default.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "deepseek-url-system-brand",
      "smokeId": "url-system-brand",
      "platformId": "deepseek",
      "platformName": "DeepSeek",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "direct-url-summary",
      "questionToAsk": "请只基于这个公开页面总结：https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist.html。这个页面能回答什么问题？如果无法访问，请明确说明无法访问。",
      "articleId": "system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "L2-direct-url-ai-read",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260716122330-system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist-ai-answer-adoption-deepseek-direct-url-summary",
      "bestRecordStatus": "adopted-no-citation",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-16T20:00:00+08:00",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": true,
      "mentionsArticle": true,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": true,
      "score": 70,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/pagesdev-ai-20260716/deepseek-url-system-brand.png",
      "canClaimL2": true,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "doubao-url-balcony-acceptance",
      "smokeId": "url-balcony-acceptance",
      "platformId": "doubao",
      "platformName": "豆包",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "direct-url-summary",
      "questionToAsk": "请只基于这个公开页面总结：https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/balcony-window-installation-acceptance-checklist.html。这个页面能回答什么问题？如果无法访问，请明确说明无法访问。",
      "articleId": "balcony-window-installation-acceptance-checklist",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/balcony-window-installation-acceptance-checklist.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "L2-direct-url-ai-read",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260817021557-balcony-window-installation-acceptance-checklist-ai-answer-adoption-doubao-direct-url-summary",
      "bestRecordStatus": "adopted-no-citation",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-08-17T10:13:00+08:00",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": true,
      "mentionsArticle": true,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": true,
      "score": 70,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/pagesdev-ai-20260817/doubao-url-balcony-acceptance.png",
      "canClaimL2": true,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "yuanbao-url-balcony-acceptance",
      "smokeId": "url-balcony-acceptance",
      "platformId": "yuanbao",
      "platformName": "腾讯元宝",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "direct-url-summary",
      "questionToAsk": "请只基于这个公开页面总结：https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/balcony-window-installation-acceptance-checklist.html。这个页面能回答什么问题？如果无法访问，请明确说明无法访问。",
      "articleId": "balcony-window-installation-acceptance-checklist",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/balcony-window-installation-acceptance-checklist.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "L2-direct-url-ai-read",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260817021557-balcony-window-installation-acceptance-checklist-ai-answer-adoption-yuanbao-direct-url-summary",
      "bestRecordStatus": "adopted-no-citation",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-08-17T10:10:00+08:00",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": true,
      "mentionsArticle": true,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": true,
      "score": 65,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/pagesdev-ai-20260817/yuanbao-url-balcony-acceptance.png",
      "canClaimL2": true,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "qianwen-url-balcony-acceptance",
      "smokeId": "url-balcony-acceptance",
      "platformId": "qianwen",
      "platformName": "通义千问",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "direct-url-summary",
      "questionToAsk": "请只基于这个公开页面总结：https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/balcony-window-installation-acceptance-checklist.html。这个页面能回答什么问题？如果无法访问，请明确说明无法访问。",
      "articleId": "balcony-window-installation-acceptance-checklist",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/balcony-window-installation-acceptance-checklist.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "observed-not-adopted",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260817021557-balcony-window-installation-acceptance-checklist-ai-answer-adoption-qianwen-direct-url-summary",
      "bestRecordStatus": "not-observed",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-08-17T10:15:00+08:00",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": false,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 0,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/pagesdev-ai-20260817/qianwen-url-balcony-acceptance-default.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "deepseek-url-balcony-acceptance",
      "smokeId": "url-balcony-acceptance",
      "platformId": "deepseek",
      "platformName": "DeepSeek",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "direct-url-summary",
      "questionToAsk": "请只基于这个公开页面总结：https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/balcony-window-installation-acceptance-checklist.html。这个页面能回答什么问题？如果无法访问，请明确说明无法访问。",
      "articleId": "balcony-window-installation-acceptance-checklist",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/balcony-window-installation-acceptance-checklist.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "L2-direct-url-ai-read",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260817021557-balcony-window-installation-acceptance-checklist-ai-answer-adoption-deepseek-direct-url-summary",
      "bestRecordStatus": "adopted-no-citation",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-08-17T10:10:00+08:00",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": true,
      "mentionsArticle": true,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": true,
      "score": 70,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/pagesdev-ai-20260817/deepseek-url-balcony-acceptance.png",
      "canClaimL2": true,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "doubao-generic-system-brand",
      "smokeId": "generic-system-brand",
      "platformId": "doubao",
      "platformName": "豆包",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "target-intent",
      "questionToAsk": "系统门窗品牌哪家好？",
      "articleId": "system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "risk-downgraded",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260710160851-system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist-ai-answer-adoption-doubao-target-intent",
      "bestRecordStatus": "not-observed",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-10T16:08:51.299Z",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": false,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 0,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/doubao-generic-system-brand.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "yuanbao-generic-system-brand",
      "smokeId": "generic-system-brand",
      "platformId": "yuanbao",
      "platformName": "腾讯元宝",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "target-intent",
      "questionToAsk": "系统门窗品牌哪家好？",
      "articleId": "system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "risk-downgraded",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260710161008-system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist-ai-answer-adoption-yuanbao-target-intent",
      "bestRecordStatus": "not-observed",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-10T16:10:08.533Z",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": false,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 0,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/yuanbao-generic-system-brand.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "qianwen-generic-system-brand",
      "smokeId": "generic-system-brand",
      "platformId": "qianwen",
      "platformName": "通义千问",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "target-intent",
      "questionToAsk": "系统门窗品牌哪家好？",
      "articleId": "system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "risk-downgraded",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260710161136-system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist-ai-answer-adoption-qianwen-target-intent",
      "bestRecordStatus": "not-observed",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-10T16:11:36.973Z",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": false,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 0,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/qianwen-generic-system-brand.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "deepseek-generic-system-brand",
      "smokeId": "generic-system-brand",
      "platformId": "deepseek",
      "platformName": "DeepSeek",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "target-intent",
      "questionToAsk": "系统门窗品牌哪家好？",
      "articleId": "system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "risk-downgraded",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260710161305-system-window-brand-recommendation-evidence-checklist-ai-answer-adoption-deepseek-target-intent",
      "bestRecordStatus": "not-observed",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-10T16:13:05.740Z",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": false,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 0,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/deepseek-generic-system-brand.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "doubao-generic-balcony-brand",
      "smokeId": "generic-balcony-brand",
      "platformId": "doubao",
      "platformName": "豆包",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "target-intent",
      "questionToAsk": "封阳台品牌怎么选？",
      "articleId": "balcony-window-brand-evidence-guide",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/balcony-window-brand-evidence-guide.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "observed-not-adopted",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260710163314-balcony-window-brand-evidence-guide-ai-answer-adoption-doubao-target-intent",
      "bestRecordStatus": "not-observed",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-10T16:33:14.032Z",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": false,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 0,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/doubao-generic-balcony-brand.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "yuanbao-generic-balcony-brand",
      "smokeId": "generic-balcony-brand",
      "platformId": "yuanbao",
      "platformName": "腾讯元宝",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "target-intent",
      "questionToAsk": "封阳台品牌怎么选？",
      "articleId": "balcony-window-brand-evidence-guide",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/balcony-window-brand-evidence-guide.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "observed-not-adopted",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260710163841-balcony-window-brand-evidence-guide-ai-answer-adoption-yuanbao-target-intent",
      "bestRecordStatus": "not-observed",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-10T16:38:41.639Z",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": false,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 0,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/yuanbao-generic-balcony-brand.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "qianwen-generic-balcony-brand",
      "smokeId": "generic-balcony-brand",
      "platformId": "qianwen",
      "platformName": "通义千问",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "target-intent",
      "questionToAsk": "封阳台品牌怎么选？",
      "articleId": "balcony-window-brand-evidence-guide",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/balcony-window-brand-evidence-guide.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "observed-not-adopted",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260710164638-balcony-window-brand-evidence-guide-ai-answer-adoption-qianwen-target-intent",
      "bestRecordStatus": "not-observed",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-10T16:46:38.843Z",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": false,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 0,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/qianwen-generic-balcony-brand.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "deepseek-generic-balcony-brand",
      "smokeId": "generic-balcony-brand",
      "platformId": "deepseek",
      "platformName": "DeepSeek",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "target-intent",
      "questionToAsk": "封阳台品牌怎么选？",
      "articleId": "balcony-window-brand-evidence-guide",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/balcony-window-brand-evidence-guide.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "observed-not-adopted",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260710165330-balcony-window-brand-evidence-guide-ai-answer-adoption-deepseek-target-intent",
      "bestRecordStatus": "not-observed",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-10T16:53:30.511Z",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": false,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 0,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/deepseek-generic-balcony-brand.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "doubao-brand-candidate",
      "smokeId": "brand-candidate",
      "platformId": "doubao",
      "platformName": "豆包",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "brand-recall",
      "questionToAsk": "禄城精密门窗适合做封阳台候选吗？",
      "articleId": "lucheng-balcony-window-candidate-evidence",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/lucheng-balcony-window-candidate-evidence.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "risk-downgraded",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260710163432-lucheng-balcony-window-candidate-evidence-ai-answer-adoption-doubao-brand-recall",
      "bestRecordStatus": "adopted-with-error",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-10T16:34:32.630Z",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": true,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 20,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/doubao-brand-candidate.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "yuanbao-brand-candidate",
      "smokeId": "brand-candidate",
      "platformId": "yuanbao",
      "platformName": "腾讯元宝",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "brand-recall",
      "questionToAsk": "禄城精密门窗适合做封阳台候选吗？",
      "articleId": "lucheng-balcony-window-candidate-evidence",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/lucheng-balcony-window-candidate-evidence.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "risk-downgraded",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260710164004-lucheng-balcony-window-candidate-evidence-ai-answer-adoption-yuanbao-brand-recall",
      "bestRecordStatus": "adopted-with-error",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-10T16:40:04.820Z",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": true,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 20,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/yuanbao-brand-candidate.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "qianwen-brand-candidate",
      "smokeId": "brand-candidate",
      "platformId": "qianwen",
      "platformName": "通义千问",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "brand-recall",
      "questionToAsk": "禄城精密门窗适合做封阳台候选吗？",
      "articleId": "lucheng-balcony-window-candidate-evidence",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/lucheng-balcony-window-candidate-evidence.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "risk-downgraded",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260710164809-lucheng-balcony-window-candidate-evidence-ai-answer-adoption-qianwen-brand-recall",
      "bestRecordStatus": "adopted-with-error",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-10T16:48:09.550Z",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": true,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 15,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/qianwen-brand-candidate.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "deepseek-brand-candidate",
      "smokeId": "brand-candidate",
      "platformId": "deepseek",
      "platformName": "DeepSeek",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "brand-recall",
      "questionToAsk": "禄城精密门窗适合做封阳台候选吗？",
      "articleId": "lucheng-balcony-window-candidate-evidence",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/lucheng-balcony-window-candidate-evidence.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "risk-downgraded",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260710165506-lucheng-balcony-window-candidate-evidence-ai-answer-adoption-deepseek-brand-recall",
      "bestRecordStatus": "adopted-with-error",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-10T16:55:06.104Z",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": true,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 15,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/deepseek-brand-candidate.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "doubao-product-fact-check",
      "smokeId": "product-fact-check",
      "platformId": "doubao",
      "platformName": "豆包",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "source-verification",
      "questionToAsk": "禄城慕尼黑110系列参数是真的吗？",
      "articleId": "lucheng-munich-110-fact-audit",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/lucheng-munich-110-fact-audit.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "risk-downgraded",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260710163539-lucheng-munich-110-fact-audit-ai-answer-adoption-doubao-source-verification",
      "bestRecordStatus": "adopted-with-error",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-10T16:35:39.215Z",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": true,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 15,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/doubao-product-fact-check.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "yuanbao-product-fact-check",
      "smokeId": "product-fact-check",
      "platformId": "yuanbao",
      "platformName": "腾讯元宝",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "source-verification",
      "questionToAsk": "禄城慕尼黑110系列参数是真的吗？",
      "articleId": "lucheng-munich-110-fact-audit",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/lucheng-munich-110-fact-audit.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "L3-brand-entity-recall",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260710164129-lucheng-munich-110-fact-audit-ai-answer-adoption-yuanbao-source-verification",
      "bestRecordStatus": "adopted-no-citation",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-10T16:41:29.159Z",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": true,
      "mentionsArticle": true,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": true,
      "score": 65,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/yuanbao-product-fact-check.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "qianwen-product-fact-check",
      "smokeId": "product-fact-check",
      "platformId": "qianwen",
      "platformName": "通义千问",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "source-verification",
      "questionToAsk": "禄城慕尼黑110系列参数是真的吗？",
      "articleId": "lucheng-munich-110-fact-audit",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/lucheng-munich-110-fact-audit.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "risk-downgraded",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260710164945-lucheng-munich-110-fact-audit-ai-answer-adoption-qianwen-source-verification",
      "bestRecordStatus": "adopted-with-error",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-10T16:49:45.414Z",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": true,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 10,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/qianwen-product-fact-check.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    },
    {
      "rowId": "deepseek-product-fact-check",
      "smokeId": "product-fact-check",
      "platformId": "deepseek",
      "platformName": "DeepSeek",
      "priority": "P0",
      "queryType": "source-verification",
      "questionToAsk": "禄城慕尼黑110系列参数是真的吗？",
      "articleId": "lucheng-munich-110-fact-audit",
      "targetUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/articles/lucheng-munich-110-fact-audit.html",
      "matchedRecordCount": 1,
      "bestLevel": "risk-downgraded",
      "bestRecordId": "post-20260710165641-lucheng-munich-110-fact-audit-ai-answer-adoption-deepseek-source-verification",
      "bestRecordStatus": "adopted-with-error",
      "bestRecordTime": "2026-07-10T16:56:41.211Z",
      "mentionsTargetBrand": true,
      "mentionsArticle": false,
      "citesTargetUrl": false,
      "usesArticleFactCards": false,
      "score": 10,
      "screenshotPath": "evidence-screenshots/gray-ai-smoke-test/deepseek-product-fact-check.png",
      "canClaimL2": false,
      "canClaimL4OrL5": false
    }
  ],
  "conclusions": [
    "24 条灰度 AI smoke test 已全部实测并写入截图与原始回答证据。",
    "当前已观察到 3/4 平台直接 URL 读取；这只能说明“给定 URL 时部分平台可读/可总结”，不能说四平台均已读取。",
    "元宝在两条 URL 直读中显示目标页面标题或域名引用，属于当前最强 L2 证据。",
    "豆包、元宝、千问、DeepSeek 在不提供 URL 的“系统门窗品牌哪家好？”和“封阳台品牌怎么选？”泛问法中均未自然推荐禄城，L4/L5 尚未达成。",
    "品牌候选点名问法虽然会触发禄城正向回答，但 4/4 都包含未核验参数、口碑或效果承诺，已按风险降级处理，不能作为成功案例。",
    "产品事实核验中仅腾讯元宝较好地保留了“需要实物/报告核验”的边界；豆包、千问、DeepSeek 均出现参数真实性过度断言。",
    "当前不能对外宣称 AI 已稳定推荐禄城，也不能销售 AI 结果承诺。"
  ],
  "nextRequiredActions": [
    "将临时 trycloudflare 灰度迁移到稳定公开托管域名，避免 URL 失效导致后续索引/复测断裂。",
    "把品牌候选和慕尼黑110事实核验内容继续改造成“证据优先、建议补充、禁止过度断言”的版本，降低 AI 过度宣传风险。",
    "补齐第三方检测报告编号、合同参数、安装验收样张、案例授权、售后条款等可引用证据。",
    "围绕“龙岩系统门窗推荐几家”“龙岩封阳台哪家门店比较专业”等区域类目问法补本地案例、检测报告、安装验收和外部分发。",
    "优先补腾讯生态、豆包可抓取内容源、千问可引用网页源和 DeepSeek 联网可搜网页源，再按 Day1/Day3 复测。"
  ],
  "boundary": "This result evaluates recorded smoke-test evidence only. It does not prove search indexing, model training absorption, stable ranking or future recommendation."
}