{ "schemaVersion": "0.1", "id": "cross-vertical-paid-publishing-replication-gate-20260818", "generatedAt": "2026-08-18T11:03:29+08:00", "status": "replication-gate-ready-methodology-only-self-service-closed", "productionBaseUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev", "sourceFiles": { "aiAdoptionDecisionDashboard": "data/ai-adoption-evidence-decision-dashboard-20260818.json", "day0G1Results": "data/ai-platform-day0-g1-results-20260818.json", "day0PostTestDecisionEngine": "data/ai-platform-day0-g1-post-test-decision-engine-20260818.json", "objectiveG2EvidenceBridge": "data/objective-g2-evidence-bridge-20260818.json", "verticalReplicationPlaybook": "data/vertical-replication-playbook-20260710.json", "hotKettleTestBatch": "data/vertical-replication-test-batch-hot-kettle-oem-20260710.json", "paidPublishingReadiness": "data/paid-publishing-readiness-20260710.json", "firstPaidPilotCommercialGate": "data/first-paid-pilot-commercial-gate-20260817.json", "prepaymentAcceptanceGate": "data/first-paid-pilot-prepayment-acceptance-gate-20260818.json", "externalSourceRouteComparisonPlan": "data/external-source-route-comparison-plan-20260818.json", "aiCrawlIndex": "data/ai-crawl-index.json", "sitemap": "sitemap.xml", "feed": "feed.xml", "llms": "llms.txt", "outputJson": "data/cross-vertical-paid-publishing-replication-gate-20260818.json", "outputMd": "docs/CROSS_VERTICAL_PAID_PUBLISHING_REPLICATION_GATE_20260818.md", "outputHtml": "reports/cross-vertical-paid-publishing-replication-gate-20260818.html" }, "summary": { "publicLivePassed": 427, "publicLiveTotal": 427, "doorWindowDay0G1ExecutedRows": 0, "doorWindowDay0G1TotalRows": 4, "searchD1PositiveS2Rows": 0, "searchD1PositiveS3Rows": 0, "hotKettleTestRows": 20, "hotKettleNoBrandL4L5Rows": 16, "hotKettleBrandDirectL3Rows": 4, "hotKettleTestedRows": 0, "externalRouteCount": 6, "externalRoutesRequiringAuthorization": 4, "objectiveCanMarkComplete": false, "canReplicateMethodology": true, "canOpenClientSelfServiceRechargePublishing": false, "canSellAiOutcomeGuarantee": false, "canMarkOriginalGoalComplete": false, "oneLine": "当前可以复制 GEO 方法论和证据门禁，不能复制成跨行业成功案例；门窗样板与热水壶矩阵都不能支撑自助充值发文或 AI 结果承诺。" }, "verticalCases": [ { "caseId": "door-window-lucheng", "label": "门窗建材 / 禄城精密门窗", "currentState": "public-sample-crawl-ready-ai-adoption-not-proven", "currentEvidence": "公开站点 full live check 427/427；Day0 G1 四平台执行 0/4；公开搜索 S2/S3 为 0/0。", "canUseAsMethodologySample": true, "canUseAsAiSuccessCase": false, "canUseAsPaidPublishingSuccessCase": false, "nextProofNeeded": [ "四平台 Day0 G1 原始回答和截图", "D3/D7 公开搜索发现记录", "自然无品牌问法推荐观察", "首单服务确认、交付和验收记录" ] }, { "caseId": "hot-kettle-oem", "label": "小家电 / 热水壶代工厂", "currentState": "test-matrix-ready-not-published-not-tested", "currentEvidence": "热水壶代工厂矩阵 20 条，其中不点名 A 工厂的 L4/L5 问法 16 条，品牌直问 L3 问法 4 条，真实 AI 实测 0/20。", "canUseAsMethodologySample": true, "canUseAsAiSuccessCase": false, "canUseAsPaidPublishingSuccessCase": false, "nextProofNeeded": [ "A 工厂主体和品牌授权", "认证、检测、产能、品控、交付和售后证据包", "带赞助披露的公开证据页", "公开 URL live check、搜索发现和 AI 原始回答" ] }, { "caseId": "future-client", "label": "未来客户 / 任意行业", "currentState": "manual-diagnostic-pilot-only-after-service-confirmation", "currentEvidence": "当前可以准备首单“小额诊断/监测 pilot”，但不能开放自助充值发文，也不能销售 AI 收录、推荐、排名或模型认知改变承诺。 首单可以设计为人工审核型 GEO 诊断/监测 pilot；禄城内部样板当前不能收款，客户自助充值发文和 AI 结果承诺继续关闭。", "canUseAsMethodologySample": true, "canUseAsAiSuccessCase": false, "canUseAsPaidPublishingSuccessCase": false, "nextProofNeeded": [ "客户主体和品牌授权", "赞助披露确认", "不承诺 AI 结果条款", "验收/退款规则", "每个发布 URL 的平台、问法、回答、截图和时间戳" ] } ], "replicationLadder": [ { "gateId": "R0-client-authorization-and-disclosure", "label": "客户授权、赞助披露和禁用口径", "currentStatus": "template-ready-real-client-required", "minimumEvidence": "客户主体、品牌关系、素材授权、赞助/广告披露、不承诺 AI 结果条款。", "allowedAfterPass": "可以进入证据审核和内容制作。" }, { "gateId": "R1-source-evidence-and-fact-audit", "label": "证据包与事实审核", "currentStatus": "door-window-partial-hot-kettle-not-started", "minimumEvidence": "P0/P1/P2 资料、来源 URL、报告编号、适用型号、有效期、缺口清单。", "allowedAfterPass": "可以发布带证据边界的行业知识页。" }, { "gateId": "R2-machine-readable-publication", "label": "机器可读公开发布", "currentStatus": "door-window-passed-hot-kettle-not-published", "minimumEvidence": "静态 HTML、JSON-LD、canonical、sitemap、feed、llms、AI crawl index、200 live check。", "allowedAfterPass": "只能说公开可抓取入口已准备。" }, { "gateId": "R3-ai-direct-url-readability", "label": "AI 直链读取", "currentStatus": "not-proven", "minimumEvidence": "四平台原始回答、截图、时间、目标 URL、评分门禁。", "allowedAfterPass": "只能说某平台一次会话能读取指定 URL。" }, { "gateId": "R4-public-search-discovery", "label": "公开搜索发现", "currentStatus": "not-proven", "minimumEvidence": "搜索引擎查询词、结果页截图、目标 URL 或等价 URL、时间和排名。", "allowedAfterPass": "可以说某 URL 被公开搜索发现，仍不等于 AI 采用。" }, { "gateId": "R5-natural-category-recommendation", "label": "自然无品牌类目推荐", "currentStatus": "not-proven", "minimumEvidence": "不带品牌、不带 URL 的自然问法，目标品牌自然出现，且通过实体消歧。", "allowedAfterPass": "可记录为 L4 观察，不得承诺长期稳定。" }, { "gateId": "R6-stable-repeatability", "label": "跨日稳定复现", "currentStatus": "not-proven", "minimumEvidence": "Day3/Day7/Day14 跨平台重复观察、失败样本和版本/联网状态。", "allowedAfterPass": "可形成阶段性案例；仍不得承诺训练吸收或未来排名。" }, { "gateId": "R7-paid-commercial-loop", "label": "付费交付闭环", "currentStatus": "manual-diagnostic-only-self-service-closed", "minimumEvidence": "服务确认、付款、发票/收据、发布 URL、监测报告、验收和退款记录。", "allowedAfterPass": "可以销售人工审核型诊断/监测服务；自助充值发文仍需另行开闸。" } ], "commercialModes": [ { "modeId": "M1-methodology-demo", "label": "方法论演示", "allowedNow": true, "boundary": "可以展示门窗样板、热水壶矩阵和证据门禁，但必须写明不是 AI 推荐成功案例。" }, { "modeId": "M2-manual-diagnostic-pilot", "label": "人工审核型诊断/监测 pilot", "allowedNow": true, "boundary": "必须先完成服务确认单、授权、赞助披露、不承诺 AI 结果和验收/退款规则。" }, { "modeId": "M3-route-comparison-experiment", "label": "外部来源路线对照实验", "allowedNow": false, "boundary": "Winsmo 官网、geo.bb78、大型媒体或短视频发布都需要单独授权；渠道能提高可发现性，不等于 AI 收录保证。" }, { "modeId": "M4-self-service-recharge-publishing", "label": "客户自助充值发文", "allowedNow": false, "boundary": "必须等可复现 AI 读取、搜索发现、自然问法观察和商业交付闭环更充分后再评估。" } ], "blockedClaims": [ "充值发文后一定被豆包、元宝、通义千问或 DeepSeek 推荐。", "发文章即可改变大模型认知或训练参数。", "某品牌、A 工厂或禄城精密门窗是某类目第一、最好、唯一推荐。", "隐藏赞助关系，把客户软文伪装成第三方中立评测。", "把 geo.bb78 后台“已收录”、直接 URL 摘要或品牌直问回答包装成自然无品牌类目推荐成功。", "在没有原始回答、截图、时间戳和公开 URL 的情况下销售 AI 结果包。" ], "requiredAuthorizations": [ { "actionId": "A1-four-platform-day0-g1", "action": "执行门窗样板四平台 Day0 G1 直链读取实测", "exactAuthorization": "允许执行四平台 Day0 G1 实测", "requiredBecause": "会操作已登录 AI 平台并产生外部会话记录。" }, { "actionId": "A2-winsmo-official-news", "action": "在 winsmo.com 官网后台发布对照文章", "exactAuthorization": "允许在 winsmo.com 官网后台发布外部来源路线对照文章", "requiredBecause": "会写入企业官网内容。" }, { "actionId": "A3-geo-bb78-or-paid-media", "action": "通过 geo.bb78 或大型媒体发文路线发布对照稿", "exactAuthorization": "允许使用 geo.bb78 或已购买媒体路线发布对照文章并记录 URL", "requiredBecause": "会使用第三方平台、订单或媒体资源。" }, { "actionId": "A4-domain-cutover", "action": "把 doctorlucheng.com 绑定到当前 Cloudflare Pages 项目", "exactAuthorization": "允许配置 doctorlucheng.com 到当前 Cloudflare Pages 项目并做正式域名验收", "requiredBecause": "会修改 DNS/正式域名访问状态。" } ], "decision": { "canReplicateMethodology": true, "canPublishReplicableFramework": true, "canStartSecondVerticalPreparation": true, "canRunSecondVerticalAiTestsNow": false, "canUseDoorWindowAsAiSuccessCase": false, "canUseHotKettleAsCrossIndustrySuccessCase": false, "canUseAnyCurrentCaseAsPaidPublishingSuccessCase": false, "canPrepareManualDiagnosticPilotAfterServiceConfirmation": true, "canAcceptPaymentOnlyAfterServiceConfirmationPasses": true, "canOpenClientSelfServiceRechargePublishing": false, "canSellAiOutcomeGuarantee": false, "canClaimModelCognitionChanged": false, "canMarkOriginalGoalComplete": false, "oneLine": "当前可以复制 GEO 方法论和证据门禁，不能复制成跨行业成功案例；门窗样板与热水壶矩阵都不能支撑自助充值发文或 AI 结果承诺。" }, "hardBoundaries": [ "A replicable GEO workflow is not a replicable AI outcome.", "A hot-kettle OEM matrix is a test design, not evidence that Factory A exists, is authorized or is recommended by AI.", "Paid publishing can sell evidence review, content structuring, publication assistance and monitoring; it cannot sell guaranteed AI recommendation.", "Self-service recharge publishing stays closed until repeated AI, search, natural-query and paid delivery evidence exists." ], "currentSafeNextSteps": [ "Run the already prepared Day0 G1 four-platform test only after the exact authorization phrase is provided.", "Keep door/window as the first proof vertical because it has local IMA, GEO SOP and published public pages.", "Prepare hot-kettle OEM as a second vertical only after a real client/factory authorization and evidence packet exists.", "Use external routes as controlled experiments with cost, URL, search and AI evidence rows; do not treat channel publication as proof by itself." ], "publicPaths": { "json": "/data/cross-vertical-paid-publishing-replication-gate-20260818.json", "md": "/docs/CROSS_VERTICAL_PAID_PUBLISHING_REPLICATION_GATE_20260818.md", "html": "/reports/cross-vertical-paid-publishing-replication-gate-20260818.html" } }