{
  "schemaVersion": "0.1",
  "id": "ai-recommendation-verification-gate-20260818",
  "generatedAt": "2026-08-18T07:29:11+08:00",
  "status": "verification-gate-open-outcome-not-proven",
  "productionBaseUrl": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev",
  "purpose": "Define the evidence gate from crawler-ready GEO article publishing to verifiable AI direct-url reading, natural recommendation and paid publishing commercial loop.",
  "sourceFiles": {
    "objectiveAudit": "data/objective-evidence-audit-20260818.json",
    "day0G1Handoff": "data/ai-platform-day0-g1-execution-handoff-20260818.json",
    "day0G1Gate": "data/ai-platform-day0-g1-result-gate-20260818.json",
    "day0G1RecorderPack": "data/ai-platform-day0-g1-result-recorder-pack-20260818.json",
    "d3ExecutionPack": "data/public-search-discovery-d3-execution-pack-20260818.json",
    "windowAiGate": "data/window-buying-pitfall-ai-result-gate-20260818.json",
    "naturalRetest": "data/local-category-natural-retest-results-20260817.json",
    "externalRoutePlan": "data/external-source-route-comparison-plan-20260818.json",
    "externalMediaFirstRowAuthorization": "data/external-media-ai-first-row-authorization-packet-20260818.json",
    "externalMediaFirstRowGate": "data/external-media-ai-first-row-result-gate-20260818.json",
    "commercialGate": "data/first-paid-pilot-commercial-gate-20260817.json",
    "outputJson": "data/ai-recommendation-verification-gate-20260818.json",
    "outputMd": "docs/AI_RECOMMENDATION_VERIFICATION_GATE_20260818.md",
    "outputHtml": "reports/ai-recommendation-verification-gate-20260818.html"
  },
  "decision": {
    "status": "verification-gate-open-outcome-not-proven",
    "canClaimPublicSiteReady": true,
    "canClaimCrawlerAccessReady": true,
    "canClaimPublicSearchDiscovery": false,
    "canClaimAiDirectUrlReadability": false,
    "canClaimNaturalRecommendation": false,
    "canClaimStableAiRecommendation": false,
    "canOpenSelfServiceRechargePublishing": false,
    "canClaimModelCognitionChanged": false,
    "canMarkOriginalGoalComplete": false,
    "oneLine": "当前已完成公开站点和爬虫可读基础设施；搜索发现、AI 直链读取、自然推荐、稳定复现和客户自助充值发文闭环仍未被证据证明。"
  },
  "summary": {
    "totalGates": 7,
    "passedGates": 2,
    "waitingGates": 2,
    "notProvenGates": 3,
    "nextD3TargetDate": "2026-08-21",
    "nextAiRow": "ai-platform-day0-g1-four-platform-run",
    "requiredAiAuthorization": "允许执行四平台 Day0 G1 实测",
    "day0G1TotalRows": 4,
    "day0G1ExecutedRows": 0,
    "day0G1NotTestedRows": 4,
    "externalRouteCount": 6,
    "currentCommercialStatus": "first-paid-diagnostic-pilot-conditionally-open-paid-publishing-closed"
  },
  "gateRows": [
    {
      "gateId": "G0-public-site-live",
      "stage": "公开站点上线",
      "status": "pass",
      "currentEvidence": "332/332 生产入口通过。",
      "proofRequiredToAdvance": "目标文章、证据页、sitemap、feed、llms.txt、AI crawl index 均可公开 200 访问。",
      "canClaim": "可声明页面公开可访问。",
      "cannotClaim": "不能声明搜索已索引、AI 已读取或自然推荐。"
    },
    {
      "gateId": "G1-crawler-access",
      "stage": "代表性爬虫可读",
      "status": "pass",
      "currentEvidence": "126/126 User-Agent × URL 访问通过。",
      "proofRequiredToAdvance": "代表性 AI / 搜索 crawler User-Agent 访问目标入口均返回 200，robots 不阻断。",
      "canClaim": "可声明抓取策略和访问层面就绪。",
      "cannotClaim": "不能声明任何平台实际抓取、训练吸收或采用。"
    },
    {
      "gateId": "G2-public-search-discovery",
      "stage": "公开搜索发现",
      "status": "waiting",
      "currentEvidence": "D1 已记录 25/25，S2/S3 正向 0/0；D3 目标日期 2026-08-21。",
      "proofRequiredToAdvance": "Google/Bing/百度/搜狗/360 至少出现目标 URL 或 canonical 等价 URL，并保留截图、查询时间、排名和摘要。",
      "canClaim": "有 S2/S3 后只能声明某搜索面可发现目标 URL。",
      "cannotClaim": "搜索发现不等于 AI 采用、AI 自然推荐或模型训练吸收。"
    },
    {
      "gateId": "G3-ai-direct-url-reading",
      "stage": "AI 直链读取",
      "status": "waiting",
      "currentEvidence": "Day0 G1 四平台 direct-url 已测 0/4，边界通过 0；买门窗 AI 批次已测 0/16，直链可读证据 0/8。",
      "proofRequiredToAdvance": "每个平台至少一条 direct-url prompt 保存原始回答、截图、时间、URL、平台和边界评分。",
      "canClaim": "有证据后可声明某平台在该次测试中可读取指定 URL。",
      "cannotClaim": "直链读取不能包装成自然无品牌推荐、搜索索引或长期稳定采用。"
    },
    {
      "gateId": "G4-natural-category-recommendation",
      "stage": "自然无品牌类目推荐",
      "status": "not-proven",
      "currentEvidence": "本轮自然无品牌问法在豆包、DeepSeek、元宝取得回答，但均未明确推荐“禄城精密门窗”；豆包只出现“芬德六扇/六扇门”相关实体信号，不能算目标品牌成功推荐；千问未捕获回答正文。",
      "proofRequiredToAdvance": "不提供 URL、不点名目标品牌的类目/区域问题中，目标品牌自然进入候选，并保留依据、不夸大、不混淆主体。",
      "canClaim": "只能按平台、问题、时间窗口声明一次观察。",
      "cannotClaim": "不能声明四平台稳定推荐或已改变模型认知。"
    },
    {
      "gateId": "G5-stable-repeat-and-source-citation",
      "stage": "跨时间稳定复现与来源引用",
      "status": "not-proven",
      "currentEvidence": "尚无跨平台、跨时间、同问法/变体问法稳定复现的正向证据。",
      "proofRequiredToAdvance": "至少 2 个平台、2 个时间窗口、同主题多个问法稳定出现目标品牌，且来源/证据边界清楚。",
      "canClaim": "可描述为阶段性稳定观察。",
      "cannotClaim": "仍不能保证未来推荐、排名或训练吸收。"
    },
    {
      "gateId": "G6-paid-publishing-commercial-loop",
      "stage": "客户付费发布闭环",
      "status": "not-proven",
      "currentEvidence": "当前可以准备首单“小额诊断/监测 pilot”，但不能开放自助充值发文，也不能销售 AI 收录、推荐、排名或模型认知改变承诺。",
      "proofRequiredToAdvance": "真实客户授权、合同/服务确认、付款、文章审核、发布、复测报告、验收/退款规则形成闭环。",
      "canClaim": "当前只能准备诊断/监测或人工审核型 pilot。",
      "cannotClaim": "不能销售 AI 收录、推荐、排名、模型认知改变或客户成交承诺。"
    }
  ],
  "nextExecutionQueue": [
    {
      "priority": 1,
      "item": "四平台 Day0 G1 direct-url 首轮实测",
      "targetDate": "收到明确授权后立即执行",
      "action": "只执行豆包、腾讯元宝、DeepSeek、千问 4 条 Day0 G1 direct-url 行，保存原始回答、截图、时间和评分。",
      "dependency": "需要用户发送精确授权句：允许执行四平台 Day0 G1 实测",
      "evidenceOutput": "data/ai-platform-day0-g1-results-20260818.json"
    },
    {
      "priority": 2,
      "item": "D3 公开搜索复测",
      "targetDate": "2026-08-21",
      "action": "按 D3 执行包记录 25 行公开搜索结果。",
      "dependency": "等待到目标日期；不需要外部写权限。",
      "evidenceOutput": "data/public-search-discovery-retest-results-template-20260818.json"
    },
    {
      "priority": 3,
      "item": "腾讯元宝外媒路线首条 direct-url 实测",
      "targetDate": "收到明确授权后立即执行",
      "action": "只测试博客园外媒 URL 的腾讯元宝 direct-url 读取与引用归因。",
      "dependency": "需要用户发送精确授权句：允许操作腾讯元宝测试外媒路线 external-media-05 direct-url-summary",
      "evidenceOutput": "data/external-media-ai-retest-results-template-current-20260818.json"
    },
    {
      "priority": 4,
      "item": "腾讯元宝 direct-url 实测 g1",
      "targetDate": "收到明确授权后立即执行",
      "action": "打开已登录腾讯元宝，测试买门窗不踩坑文章 direct-url 读取。",
      "dependency": "需要用户发送精确授权句：允许操作腾讯元宝测试买门窗不踩坑文章 g1",
      "evidenceOutput": "data/window-buying-pitfall-ai-retest-results-20260818.json"
    },
    {
      "priority": 5,
      "item": "外部来源路线一条对照实验",
      "targetDate": "用户选择并授权路线后执行",
      "action": "从官网、doctorlucheng、geo.bb78、历史外媒或付费大媒中选择一条路线，对同主题文章做 URL/搜索/AI 对照。",
      "dependency": "需要明确授权对应后台、域名或付费渠道；本包不执行外部写入。",
      "evidenceOutput": "data/external-source-route-comparison-plan-20260818.json"
    },
    {
      "priority": 6,
      "item": "首单小额诊断/监测 pilot",
      "targetDate": "客户确认服务单后执行",
      "action": "按服务确认单销售诊断、证据审核、内容结构、AI 可见性监测，不销售结果承诺。",
      "dependency": "需要客户主体、品牌授权、赞助披露、无结果承诺条款和验收规则。",
      "evidenceOutput": "data/first-paid-pilot-commercial-gate-20260817.json"
    }
  ],
  "hardBoundaries": [
    "公开可访问和 crawler 200 只证明 L0/L1，不证明平台实际抓取或采用。",
    "搜索结果出现目标 URL 只证明搜索发现，不证明 AI 回答采用。",
    "direct-url 读取只证明给定 URL 的单次可读，不证明自然推荐。",
    "自然推荐必须是不点名品牌、不提供 URL 的类目/区域问法中自然进入候选。",
    "任何单轮自然提及都不能升级为稳定推荐或模型认知改变。",
    "付费产品现阶段只能卖诊断、证据审核、内容结构、发布台账和 AI 可见性监测，不能卖结果保证。"
  ],
  "publicUrls": {
    "json": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/data/ai-recommendation-verification-gate-20260818.json",
    "md": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/docs/AI_RECOMMENDATION_VERIFICATION_GATE_20260818.md",
    "html": "https://lucheng-geo.pages.dev/reports/ai-recommendation-verification-gate-20260818.html"
  }
}